Not everyone has $20 million+ to flip a Senate seat. Some folks have to make do with a compelling candidate, strong on-the-ground organizing, and a campaign manager willing to hold a boom mic to keep costs low on ad shoots.
Senator-elect Scott Colom did exactly that in a campaign that proved a lot of people wrong about what Democrats — and Black voters — can accomplish in the South.
This week, I connected with Helen Hare and Marina Orcutt, partners at Watershed Strategies, who ran paid digital media for the campaign. Alongside Michael J. Brewer, Ryan Sayles, Colom’s twin brother Andrew, and many others, they helped build local excitement about a candidate long before he got the national attention he deserved.
I think you’ll get a lot out of their insights into creating compelling content on a smaller budget, why Colom’s “Mississippi Matters” message resonated, and what Democrats can learn from his victory.
THIS IS ON BACKGROUND
Six short questions, six quick answers featuring the wisdom of Watershed Strategies partners Helen Hare and Marina Orcutt. Both are Patty Murray alums, with experience spanning the Obama White House, Senate HELP Committee, and senior roles at the DSCC.
I’m curious about the creative strategy on this campaign. And what made you all comfortable taking risks on videos like ‘Pick Another Protein’ and the spoof on Sinners?
We loved both of these videos and can’t take credit for them! Ryan Sayles, Scott’s content creator, produced Protein as an organic video. Scott’s brother Andrew R. Colom did the same for Sinators.
This was such a deeply creative campaign. It had to be. When Scott brought us on in May 2025, outside of the campaign team and Scott’s family and friends, you could count the number of people who thought we had a shot on one hand.
From the start, Scott made clear he wanted to run a different kind of campaign focused on faith, family, sports, and spreading the word that Mississippi matters. He cared deeply–as every candidate should—about his video content always conveying those values in creative ways that brought attention to the race.
As a former digital director and communications director, we know how much the media environment has changed. We always recommend that our clients try to align what’s happening on earned and organic with paid digital media to reinforce one another. With respect to this race, we also knew that with so much to build and so few resources, we had to take strategic risks to reach the audiences who needed to hear about and believe in Scott’s path to victory. This was especially true for Black voters, who are such a critical part of the electorate everywhere, but particularly in Mississippi.
With all this in mind, we looked for ways to get attention and deliver the campaign’s message in a way that made the most of the campaign’s limited budget.
The campaign’s first digital buy was in November 2025 around the Egg Bowl, Mississippi’s annual football showdown between Ole Miss and Mississippi State. It is the state’s highest-viewership sporting event, one of its most unifying cultural moments, and a perfect opportunity to tell voters about Scott. Scott is not only a huge sports fan, he’s also a dad who knows firsthand that prices are going up for Mississippi families. With households across Mississippi tuning in, Watershed saw a chance for Scott to introduce himself in a unique way that could generate interest from press and enthusiasm from grassroots and major donors. We produced Tailgate with a small paid budget and ran targeted ads to voters on their phones, laptops, and TVs, all in an environment where the creative felt like a natural part of their game day experience.
We then produced two more long-form storytelling videos, Farmers Deserve Better and Never Quit. We recommended and shot the Mississippi farmer ad because we kept seeing headlines across the state about tariffs hurting rural farmers. We produced “Never Quit” to communicate Scott’s Christian faith and values early on.
All three of these followed the same pattern as Protein. They were produced at a nontraditional length of more than 60 seconds and initially posted on organic platforms. Then they were cut down into paid ads (we ran Farmer and Never Quit as primary ads back in early 2026, and placed Protein on CTV after it broke the internet this fall).
In short, from the start and as a direct result of Scott’s vision, risk-taking was a core part of the campaign’s strategy, and a major reason why he ultimately connected with voters so authentically and won.
The senator-elect has talked about how difficult it was to raise money because national folks overlooked his race. What did you do differently to make up for having fewer resources than other Dem candidates in high-profile races?
A lot of this goes back to the same broad strategy of taking risks to generate attention, build momentum, and help voters understand what made Scott different. At a more granular level, we worked to do a lot with a little whenever we could. Some examples:
Keeping shoot costs as low as possible. When we shot Tailgate, Ryan Sayles was behind the camera, but Scott’s campaign manager Gerard Henderson was holding the boom mic!
Coordinating digital media and fundraising. We gave the fundraising teams enough runway to prep for the Tailgate placement around the Egg Bowl. Grassroots donations increased during the three hours of the game, which aligns with a pattern we have seen anecdotally: communicating with voters during high-engagement cultural moments can coincide with elevated fundraising performance. Big dollar donations also increased, because the ad provided both the candidate and the campaign team an additional opportunity to reach back out to some donors who had not yet contributed.
Running basic static ads at a low spend for name ID. When we needed to raise Scott’s name ID with Black voters even though fundraising was slow over the summer, we ran a small but consistent static ad buy featuring Scott and his family, just to make sure as many people as possible had seen something positive about him before negative ads started coming in the fall.
Importantly, all of our digital media reinforced an enormous amount of on-the-ground organizing and campaigning by Scott, his family, and the campaign team. Voters who saw digital content were also hearing about the Pick Another Protein food truck that made stops across Mississippi and hearing about how Scott was visiting all 82 counties in Mississippi.
Compensating for the fundraising challenges took a lot of hustle across every facet of the campaign, but we loved it.
Any advice you’d give to other candidates in the South or red states facing the same kind of skepticism about their prospects?
It’s time for that kind of skepticism to disappear. We just saw so many incredible candidates overcoming the conventional wisdom. Voters are so eager for authentic candidates like Scott who know their communities inside and out, and if it can happen in Mississippi, it can happen anywhere.
One of the many things that helped this campaign was its discipline around communicating intentionally to the audiences who mattered most, namely Mississippians. A lot of people were shocked to see how well Scott was doing on election night, but he wasn’t, because Mississippi was the audience for this campaign, not the country.
The more you can match what you spend time on during your campaign with the audiences that are part of your path to victory, the better you’re using the resources you do have available to you.
Finally, don’t give up! As Ryan Sayles said on election day in Mississippi, we used to think we were cooking with 120 likes. The breakout moment that looks like it happened overnight is probably the result of a lot of work to create the conditions for that kind of momentum.
What’s one thing the national audience and folks in D.C. have missed about this race?
To be honest, most of the national audience and D.C. missed the whole thing! It’s been such a joy to see the country experience what we got to see over the last year and a half–so much that’s wonderful about the state of Mississippi and their new Senator.
One thing we’ve been thinking about is how much this campaign stood out from the stiff and transactional way politics can feel today. If you got to be in Mississippi to see Scott and his team in action, you knew this was truly a whole-of-community effort that brought voters in and built connection and trust. That’s more important than ever.
What do you want to shout from the rooftops?
We keep seeing election cycle after election cycle that, unless you’re a star of a candidate nationally, campaign support in the form of donations is coming in later and later. Too often, that means quality video creative and opportunities for storytelling and relationship–building with voters online get delayed or cut out.
That doesn’t have to happen. Even with limited resources on Scott’s campaign, we ran scrappy, effective digital paid media campaigns from 2025 to 2026 that connected with Mississippi households and introduced Scott, his family, and his values. That’s something that all our campaigns need to continue to iterate on, test, and improve.
Who else should we make time to talk to?
You may know Michael J. Brewer, who was the senior advisor for communications on the Colom campaign, and previously held senior roles with Senator Warnock. More people should hear his perspective on the future of politics in the South. Gerard Henderson was Scott’s campaign manager and has a lot to say about how to overcome skepticism and beat the odds.



